Qualitative critique requires deep understanding of the topic as well as knowledge regarding various methods of research and analysis to get the best results. As someone who works in the security industry for ten years, I find this argument quite compelling and worth listening to.
Free Essays Tags The data that she collected seems to be relatively clear and explicit. The themes are emergent throughout the report and arise directly out of excerpted commentary on the part of the participants themselves.
That is, Lethal, by providing continuous excerpts from interviews allowed the participants to speak for themselves while keeping with the structured questions she outlined in the description of her procedure.
The quotes given by her participants are powerful and confirm the importance of the study to understand the challenges of older nurses. The description of her procedures was sufficient, but leaves questions for the reader.
For example, Lethal revived several participants the opportunity to review the results to insure validity. However, while this is part of the third stage of undertaking a case study Sideman, it is not clear that these two participants were appropriately representative of the greater sample of participants nor does the author offer any evidence of how these two participants were selected as critics.
The researchers qualification as a PHD level nurse also provides confidence in her understanding of how to conduct research and the trustworthiness of her findings. However, her nursing background and experience are not mentioned.
It would be helpful for the reader to know more of her personal background and academic affiliations. The confidence of this study would be enhanced if there was an understanding of how knowledgeable the researcher was in the areas of chronic pain and depression Merriam, Many nursing readers of all ages will be able to easily relate to the participants of this study.
The results of this phenomenological study not only provides meaningful evidence that older nurses are struggling to provide proper care of their patients because of their own physical and mental challenges, but also gives examples of coping strategies that can be used by other hurting nurses.Critique of Quantitative Research In: Other Topics Submitted By Jishu Words " Qualitative research focuses on deeper issues and asked the questions of how, when and why people do things.
Research critique Background Regnier Denois, V., Poirson J., Nourissat A., Jacquin J., Guastalla J.
P, & Chauvin F. () European Journal of. Qualitative Research Critique There are many differences between quantitative and qualitative research. Such things like: quantitative research provides only variables that can predict specific results but it does not tell us very much about how the variables affect an individual’s life course.
Quantitative Critique Essay examples; Quantitative Critique Essay examples.
Words Feb 11th, 7 Pages. Research Methods This research is a qualitative study using the phenomenological-hermenetic method. & Gejerman’s Study “Survivorship Health Information Counseling for Patients with Prostate Cancer” Laura Laughbaum, SN. Qualitative Research Article Critique Essay Sample.
Qualitative research is “the investigation of phenomena, typically in an in-depth and holistic fashion, through the collection of rich narrative materials using a flexible research design” (Polit, Beck, and Hungler, , p ). Qualitative Research Critique Laura B. Laughbaum, SN Lake Superior State University Qualitative Research Critique Presentation Susan Letvak provided an enjoyable to read narrative approach to research reporting.
The article was well-written and well-organized in sufficient detail for critical analysis. The quantitative research I have chosen to critique is "A new perspective on VBAC: A retrospective cohort study." (Rozen, Ugoni, & Sheehan, ).
The purpose of this critique is to evaluate the research this study provides related to VBAC delivery and evidence-based nursing practice.